Sapience vs Sentience

jedion357's picture
Printer-friendly version

 

or Intelligence for Civilization

Sapience and sentience have been used, often interchangeably, in science fiction to describe alien species as being equal to humanity in intelligence and rights. The words however do not mean the same thing. Sapience comes from the Latin root for wisdom and means the ability to use judgment. Sentience is the ability to feel, perceive and have consciousness.  Animal rights activist often argue their cause based on the belief that animals have sentience. I would be inclined to agree that animals perceive and feel and have a consciousness but would question an assertion that they have the ability to exercise judgment.

Sapience would be an indicator of the ability to make moral judgments and decisions which is a building block to civilization. To put it another way it’s an ability to advance the cause of one’s species. Sentience is an indicator of an ability to intelligently advance the cause of one’s personal needs.

For science fiction I would use a categorization of sentience for intelligent animals with a scale of -, 0, and +. A minus would be a very intelligent breed of dogs, a zero would be a primate but a + would be an animal that is coming up against the sapience barrier. These plus animals are beginning to show signs of an ability to organize and transmit culture. The same would go for sapience -, 0, and +. Arbitrarily I rate humanity as a zero on this scale.

The concept of the sapience barrier is recognition of the fact that true sapience is a very rare thing. On Earth there are 2 million species identified by science of an estimated 5 million to 100 million species currently living and only one that registers as sapient.  The odds are fairly long for sapience. In a science fiction setting a sapient species ought to be rare.

However, if abundant life, like Earth’s ecosystem, arises on a planet then we should expect tremendous variety of that life. So any time a planet exists with abundant life we could expect 5-100 million species living on that planet. Thus the mere presence of abundant life skews the numbers to have at least one dominant “sentient plus” species or a full on sapient one.

Often as not we hear that the odds for the chance of life elsewhere in the universe are long odds but the counterpoint is that a barren universe would not be as interesting as a populated one. I’m betting on an interesting universe no matter what the odds are.

teon33
Римская империя мировая

Римская империя мировая история рождение британии.
Материалы по математике алгебра и геометрия история великой теоремы ферма.
Садовые деревья и кустарники книги для садовода огород без вредителей.
Дипломные работы по бухгалтерскому учету скачать рефераты по бухучету учебные материалы по бухучету.
Лекарственные психозы странности нашего тела чудо релаксации.

clibin009
clb0111

clb0111

ralph lauren outlet online fitflops sale polo ralph lauren outlet michael kors outlet store adidas ultra boost ray ban sunglasses discount ralph lauren uk birkin handbags ugg boots outlet canada goose outlet christian louboutin shoes christian louboutin shoes canada goose outlet store pandora charms sale clearance nike outlet online canada goose retro 11 louis vuitton factory outlet fitflop sandals canada goose sale polo ralph lauren outlet online nike zoom ugg boots sale michael kors burberry handbags coach factory outlet online nike outlet store ugg outlet ralph lauren outlet online uggs clearance ralph lauren uk adidas nmd runner adidas nmd runner pandora jewelry coach factory outlet pandora charms sale clearance moncler pas cher pandora jewelry store ferragamo shoes coach factory outlet online christian louboutin sale coach outlet canada coach outlet store mlb jerseys cheap ugg boots pandora charms sale clearance canada goose moncler jackets canada goose coats gucci outlet online polo ralph lauren outlet coach purses michael kors outlet clearance canada goose jackets yeezy shoes coach factory outlet moncler coats adidas store coach outlet store online kate spade handbags michael kors handbags outlet michael kors outlet online ray bans nike outlet store online coach outlet online michael kors outlet online michael kors tory burch outlet online air max the north face outlet ugg outlet polo ralph lauren outlet online longchamps ugg outlet moncler uk pandora jewelry cheap ray ban sunglasses pandora charms moncler pandora uk louboutin outlet ralph lauren michael kors cheap jordans free shipping yeezy shoes coach outlet online canada goose outlet adidas nmd r1 ferragamo outlet coach outlet online coach factory outlet online moncler jackets adidas shoes kate spade outlet online mulberry uk supreme clothing nike air max 2018 cheap jordan shoes ray ban sunglasses discount cheap ugg boots canada goose coats uggs on sale salvatore ferragamo outlet timberland outlet michael kors outlet online polo ralph lauren outlet ugg boots michael kors outlet clearance fitflop shoes michael kors bags coach outlet online canada goose jackets polo ralph lauren moncler sale kate spade handbags coach outlet online kate spade handbags christian louboutin shoes air max shoes burberry handbags nmd adidas adidas superstar shoes pandora charms pandora outlet michael kors outlet online yeezy boost 350 louboutin outlet ugg canada pandora charms sale yeezy boost 350 hermens oakley sunglasses outlet oakley sunglasses outlet nike outlet online nike air max 97 uggs outlet mbt ralph lauren uk pandora sale clearance cheap nfl jerseys wholesale michael kors outlet online north face outlet ralph lauren michael kors outlet online moncler outlet online adidas yeezy boost 350 michael kors outlet canada red bottom canada goose outlet cheap jordans for sale mbt uggs outlet moncler coats supreme shirts polo ralph lauren cheap nike shoes pandora outlet canada goose jacket coach factory outlet online uggs outlet adidas yeezy boost harden vol 1 cheap ray ban sunglasses adidas yeezy boost pandora charms outlet canada goose coats michael kors outlet online pandora jewelry ugg boots canada goose jackets moncler jackets ralph lauren outlet online michael kors coach outlet online coach outlet online the north face outlet ugg outlet store mlb jerseys longchamp outlet store coach outlet canada ralph lauren ralph lauren outlet online coach factory outlet online ugg boots women hermes bags canada goose outlet pandora charms moncler outlet online canada goose jackets ugg boots coach outlet online canada goose jackets pandora jewelry outlet kate spade outlet pandora charms sale clearance birkenstock outlet burberry handbags ralph lauren outlet online ugg boots michael kors outlet clearance burberry outlet online burberry outlet moncler uk canada goose jackets adidas outlet store cheap jordan shoes kate spade outlet online fred perry shirts cheap air jordans canada goose jackets michael kors outlet online ugg boots nike sneakers canada goose outlet online louis vuitton factory outlet discount ray ban sunglasses mulberry burberry outlet online coach outlet online canada goose parka timberland boots ugg boots michael kors bags kate spade handbags nike air max 2018 canada goose coats cheap ugg boots canada goose jackets cheap ugg boots michael kors handbags cheap jordan shoes ugg sale ugg boots outlet polo outlet online uggs moncler sale coach outlet online canada goose coats canada goose coach factory outlet online canada goose outlet timberland outlet store salvatore ferragamo shoes michael kors outlet store michael kors outlet store canada goose jackets pandora charms sale longchamp bags adidas yeezy north face sale ray ban sunglasses outlet canada goose sale pandora charms outlet canada goose jackets cheap oakley sunglasses michael kors outlet store louis vuitton handbags nike shoes canada goose jackets philipp plein outlet canada goose jackets fitflops sale clearance moncler outlet online adidas outlet store kate spade outlet online philipp plein fitflops sale air jordan retro uggs outlet pandora charms outlet coach outlet online fred perry polo shirts discount oakley sunglasses ugg outlet store pandora jewelry outlet coach factory outlet online canada goose jackets canada goose jackets uk coach outlet online canada goose sale ugg outlet store yeezy boost 350 adidas sneakers uggs outlet cheap oakley sunglasses uggs outlet ugg outlet online kate spade outlet online canada goose outlet online coach outlet online mulberry outlet uk ugg boots michael kors outlet store gucci outlet louis vuitton outlet longchamp sale coach outlet store online clearance coach outlet store bottes ugg moncler coats supreme shirts adidas adidas outlet longchamp bags the north face outlet uggs outlet pandora charms outlet canada goose pandora jewelry cheap oakley sunglasses nfl jerseys ugg boots louis vuitton outlet online michael kors coach factory outlet online longchamp outlet ugg outlet north face outlet air jordans ray ban sunglasses outlet hermes outlet michael kors outlet clearance burberry outlet online air jordan shoes cheap jordans jordan shoes for sale adidas yeezy louis vuitton factory outlet ralph lauren outlet online adidas yeezy shoes nike outlet store michael kors outlet clearance cheap air jordans polo ralph lauren outlet online adidas superstars ralph lauren sale adidas outlet online fitflop sandals hermes bag yeezy boost ralph lauren outlet online louboutin shoes red bottoms michael kors outlet store mbt shoes sale coach factorty outlet online nfl jerseys michael kors outlet store coach factory outlet online ralph lauren outlet online coach outlet store online ugg outlet coach factorty outlet online nike sneakers louis vuitton outlet store michael kors outlet store oakley sunglasses outlet ralph lauren outlet valentino uggs outlet moncler jacket yeezy boost 350 coach outlet online cheap air jordans michael kors outlet canada cheap uggs uggs outlet yeezy shoes ugg boots outlet ugg outlet store columbia sportswear outlet coach outlet store louis vuitton outlet online coach outlet pandora uk cheap oakley sunglasses coach factory outlet online supreme uk canada goose jackets valentino outlet coach outlet online polo ralph lauren outlet online north face jackets ugg outlet online ralph lauren coach outlet online canada goose jackets polo ralph lauren outlet coach factory outlet polo ralph lauren outlet online birkenstock shoes canada goose coats uggs outlet ray ban glasses coach outlet store online polo ralph lauren outlet coach factory outlet online coach outlet online adidas campus shoes hermes handbags uggs clearance canada goose sale the north face jackets caterpillar boots kate spade outlet adidas nmd r1 tory burch shoes polo ralph lauren outlet adidas outlet online coach outlet online adidas nmd r1 michael kors outlet online canada goose sale adidas yeezy boost uggs outlet moncler outlet online coach factory outlet ralph lauren uk canada goose outlet canada goose jackets ugg boots ugg boots cheap ugg boots nike outlet ugg canada air max cheap jordan shoes ugg outlet online oakley sunglasses for women ray ban sunglasses sale cheap nfl jerseys wholesale coach factory outlet nike shoes coach outlet online uggs outlet jordans canada goose jackets michael kors outlet red bottom heels hermes bags coach handbags outlet coach outlet online nike air max 97 canada goose jackets ralph lauren sale uggs on sale nfl jerseys adidas nmd r1 timberland outlet oakley sunglasses outlet uggs outlet polo ralph lauren outlet north face jackets ugg cheap jordan shoes canada goose jackets coach outlet online ugg boots mulberry handbagsclb0111